FILM 2013: #39. V/H/S
A problem with V/H/S, shared by practically any anthology or portmanteau piece, is that it’s very hit and miss. Here the framework - a group of obnoxious vandals break into a house to steal a videotape and find a whole bounty of weird footage - is fine, but it’s obvious that there wasn’t a lot of pre-planning as to what films would end up in the package. Many of the stories share similar structures (most starting with a group videoing themselves in a car on a journey somewhere), leaving it feeling pretty repetitive, and while they all sell the found-footage angle (the how, as opposed to the why), few convince on the nostalgic VHS remit (heck, one is filmed through a web video chat). It’s a shame, as each story has one cool trick or killer moment, but you have to go through an awful lot of pre-amble and unlikeable characters to get there. And with 5 stories, plus the framing narrative, it gets very tiresome. It’s perhaps why the strongest story (10/31/98 by directing team Radio Silence) is shown last (even after the framework is resolved), and is almost worth putting up with the rest of the film to see - an atmospheric, exciting and brilliant tale of a Halloween night that takes a terrifying turn, creative and inventive while having the technical and special effects expertise to match it on a small budget. Out of the more established American indie wunderkinds like Joe Swanberg, Ti West and Adam Wingard present here, there’s is the real highlight. The format is decent enough for the sequel to still be an interesting proposition, but hopefully next time they’ll learn from their mistakes.
Source: will2kill




